Back to the blog
Small business

Hiring Your First Employee: What You Are Getting Into, and the Steps Before Day One

Hiring Your First Employee: What You Are Getting Into, and the Steps Before Day One

Hiring your first employee usually starts with a week when there is too much work and not enough of you. You have quoted jobs you could not start, sent invoices at midnight, and said "I need help" out loud more than once. Then you sit down to do something about it and the questions pile up. What does a person really cost? What do I have to register? What if I get this wrong?

Before hiring your first employee, write down the three tasks the person would own and what each one costs you now, then work out the full cost of the role (wage, employer taxes, insurance and your own training time) and check you can pay it every payday. Only then register as an employer and advertise.

This guide is for solo owners and very small businesses taking on their first part-time or full-time person. It covers how to tell you are ready, why first hires go wrong, what they really cost, a step-by-step plan with official links for the US and the UK, what to do if a first hire has already gone badly, and how to make the second one easier. It is general guidance, not legal, tax or employment advice. Employment law and payroll taxes differ by country and by state, so talk to an accountant and, for the contract and anything that goes wrong, an employment lawyer about your own case.

Is this you?

  • You are turning work down, or starting it late, because there is only one of you.
  • You know you need help but cannot say exactly what the person would do all day.
  • You have a number in your head for the wage and no idea what sits on top of it.
  • You are not sure whether the person should be an employee or a contractor, or whether you even get to choose.
  • You hired someone before, it did not work out, and you suspect the problem was partly you.
  • You do not know who to ask, so you have asked nobody.

If several of these sound familiar, you are at the most common point of growth for a small business. Feeling out of your depth here is normal: nobody is taught this before they need it.

Why first hires go wrong

The job is "help", not a job

Most first hires are made in a rush, to relieve pressure. The owner knows they are overloaded, so they hire someone to "help with everything". The new person arrives to no clear tasks, gets handed whatever is most urgent that day, and is judged against a standard that was never written down. Both sides end up frustrated, and the owner concludes that staff are more trouble than they are worth.

The wage is treated as the cost

The wage is the part you see, so it is the part people budget for. On top of it sit employer payroll taxes, insurance that is often compulsory, holiday and sick pay, a workplace pension in some countries, payroll software or an accountant's time, equipment, and the hours you spend training. In the US, the Bureau of Labor Statistics found that across private employers in June 2026, wages were 70% of the cost of employing someone and benefits, including legally required ones such as employer payroll taxes, made up the other 30% (Employer Costs for Employee Compensation, Bureau of Labor Statistics, September 2026). That is an average across businesses of every size, not a rule for yours, but it shows why the wage alone understates the real cost.

The paperwork is invisible until it is late

Becoming an employer comes with a set of one-off steps (registering, checking the right to work, insurance) and a set of recurring ones (running payroll, paying over taxes, filing returns). None of them is hard on its own. The trouble is that a first-time employer does not know the list exists, and some steps have to happen before the first payday, not after.

The contractor question gets answered by habit

Many owners pay their first helper as a contractor because it feels simpler. But in most countries you do not get to choose the label: it depends on how the work is actually done. The IRS looks at behavioural control, financial control and the type of relationship, and the key question is how far you have "the right to direct and control the worker" (Independent contractor or employee?, IRS). In the UK, someone is probably an employee if most of a list of conditions apply, such as being required to work regularly and having a manager who controls their workload (Employment status: employee, GOV.UK). If you set the hours, supply the tools and tell them how to do the job, calling them a contractor does not make them one.

What it costs if you get it wrong

A payroll you cannot meet. Wages are due on payday whether or not your clients have paid you. In Billbooks invoice data, The typical invoice is paid 9 days after it is issued; one in ten takes 57 days or longer. (Source: Billbooks invoice data.) One slow client in the wrong month can leave a wage bill with nothing to pay it from.

Back taxes and penalties for the wrong classification. If a "contractor" turns out to have been an employee, the employer can owe the taxes and contributions that should have been paid, plus penalties and interest, and the worker may be owed pay and rights they never had. The US Department of Labor notes that minimum wage and overtime protections apply to employees and not to properly classified contractors (Misclassification of employees as independent contractors, US Department of Labor).

Your time, twice. A person with no clear job needs constant direction. You pay their wage and still spend your evenings doing or redoing their work, which is why some owners decide they were better off alone.

A relationship that is hard to end. Once someone is your employee, letting them go carries obligations: notice, final pay, sometimes a fair process you must follow. An unclear role makes that conversation harder, because neither of you can point to what the job was supposed to be.

What to do now: a step-by-step plan

You need a spreadsheet or a notebook, your last few months of income and expenses, and an hour with an accountant before you advertise.

1. Write the job before you write the advert

List the three tasks the person would own outright, not "help with". For each one, note how many hours a week it takes you now and what it would earn or save if someone else did it. Quoting and invoicing, site prep, booking jobs, answering the phone. If you cannot name three, you may need a few hours of a contractor or a service, not an employee yet.

2. Price the role fully, not just the wage

Add up the wage, then ask your accountant what the employer taxes and compulsory insurance come to where you are, and add holiday and sick pay, any pension contribution, payroll software, equipment and your own training hours for the first three months. That total, not the hourly rate, is what you are committing to every month. Compare it with the work the person will free you to do.

3. Check the money arrives before the wage leaves

Look at when your clients actually pay, not when they are due to. If wages go out on the 15th and most of your money lands on the 30th, you need either a cash buffer or a pay date that fits your cash. Plan for at least one month where a big client pays late.

check payday against your cash

Will the money be there when the wage is due?

Enter what you are owed, when it usually arrives and what goes out, and see whether a gap opens before your next payday. The Cash Gap Check takes two minutes and needs no signup.

Run the cash gap check

4. Decide employee or contractor on the facts

Ask how the work will really be done. Will you set the hours, the place and the method? Will they use your tools and work only for you? Then it is probably employment, whatever you call it. Read the official guidance for your country, and if it is genuinely unclear, ask your accountant or an employment lawyer before the person starts, not after.

5. Do the employer setup before day one

The official checklists are short and worth reading end to end:

  • In the US, the SBA lists the steps: get an Employer Identification Number, check for state or local tax IDs, decide contractor or employee, collect a completed Form W-4, set pay periods, choose how you will run payroll, know which records to keep, and report payroll taxes (Hire and manage employees, SBA). Every new hire also completes Form I-9, which verifies their identity and that they are allowed to work in the US (Form I-9, USCIS). Most states require you to report new hires and to carry workers' compensation insurance, so check your state's rules too.
  • In the UK, GOV.UK sets out the steps in order: check you can afford it (minimum wage, National Insurance, sick pay, pensions, parental pay), make the workplace safe, register as an employer and set up PAYE, set up a workplace pension, get Employers' Liability insurance, then recruit (Employ someone for the first time: step by step, GOV.UK). You must register with HMRC before the first payday, and you cannot register more than two months before you start paying people (Register as an employer, GOV.UK). You must also check the person's right to work in the UK before they start.
  • Elsewhere, your tax authority almost certainly publishes a first-employer guide. Start there, then take it to your accountant.

6. Put the agreement in writing

A short written contract or statement of terms protects you both: pay, hours, place of work, holiday, notice, and what the job is. In many places some of this must be in writing by law. An employment lawyer can check a template for an hour's fee, which is cheap compared with a dispute.

7. Plan the first two weeks

Write down what "done well" looks like for each of the three tasks, the one or two things that must never go wrong, and when to ask you. Hand over one task at a time. Check the results, not every step. Book a short review at the end of week two and month three, so problems come up while they are small.

If it has already happened

If you hired someone and paid them as a contractor, and now you are not sure, do not wait for someone else to raise it. Speak to an accountant now. Correcting a classification early is usually far simpler and cheaper than having it discovered later.

If you have missed a registration or a payroll filing, register or file as soon as you can and tell your accountant. Tax authorities generally treat a business that comes forward and catches up better than one that waits to be found.

If the person is not working out, first ask whether they ever had a clear job. If not, write it down now and give them a fair chance against it. If it still is not working, take advice from an employment lawyer or your local employer advice service before you end the arrangement, because the process matters as much as the reason.

If your last hire went badly and you blame yourself, you are in good company. Most owners learn to manage people by getting it wrong once. Write down what was unclear (the tasks, the standard, the hours, the money) and fix those before the next hire.

If payroll is already putting the business under strain, talk to your accountant before you miss a payday, not after. Unpaid wages carry legal duties. Our guide for owners who are behind on the bills and the wages sets out who to call first.

How to make the second hire easier

Keep the job description alive. Every time something goes wrong, change the written standard, not the person. By the second hire you will have a job description, a checklist and a two-week plan ready to reuse.

Get paid faster than you pay out. Payroll is fixed and client payments are not, so the gap between them is now your problem every month. Invoice the day the work is done, ask for deposits on larger jobs, and chase late payers on a schedule rather than when you remember.

Give the hire their own access, not your password. If the person will send invoices or record payments, give them their own login with only the permissions they need. In Billbooks that is a team member account (2 users on the Basic plan, 5 on Standard, 10 on Professional), and automatic reminders chase late payers so the wage does not wait on your memory. Billbooks does not run payroll, so use a payroll service or your accountant for that. Before you add people to any software, see what happens to your software bill when you hire.

Review the numbers after three months. Compare what the role costs with what it freed you to do. If the business earns more, or you work fewer evenings for the same money, the hire is working. If not, the job probably needs redefining, not abandoning.

Two free tools to check you can afford the hire and see the hours it frees

Frequently asked questions

What do I need to do before hiring my first employee?

Write down the tasks the person will own, work out the full cost of the role, and check you can pay it every payday. Then register as an employer with your tax authority, check the person can legally work for you, arrange any compulsory insurance, set up payroll and put the terms in writing before they start.

How much does a first employee really cost on top of the wage?

More than the wage. Employer payroll taxes, compulsory insurance, holiday and sick pay, any pension contribution, payroll software and your own training time all sit on top. Across US private employers in June 2026, benefits including legally required ones were about 30% of total compensation cost, but your figure depends on your country, state and role, so ask an accountant.

Should my first hire be an employee or a contractor?

It depends on how the work is done, not on what you call it. If you set the hours, the place and the method, supply the tools and they work only for you, they are probably an employee. Read your tax authority's guidance, and ask an accountant or employment lawyer if it is genuinely unclear.

Do I need to register as an employer before my first employee starts?

In most countries, yes, before the first payday. In the US that means an Employer Identification Number and any state registrations. In the UK you must register with HMRC before the first payday and cannot register more than two months before you start paying people.

What paperwork does a new employee fill in?

In the US, a new employee completes Form W-4 for tax withholding and Form I-9 to verify identity and the right to work, and most states require you to report new hires. In the UK you check the right to work and set the person up on PAYE. Other countries have their own equivalents.

When can a small business afford its first employee?

When the full monthly cost of the role is covered by the work the person frees you to do, and you have enough cash to pay wages through a month when a big client pays late. If you cannot yet name three tasks the person would own, a contractor or a few hours of outside help may fit better.

The one thing to do today

Write the job. On one page, list the three tasks the person would own, how many hours each takes you now, and what you would do with those hours instead. If the page is easy to fill in, take it to your accountant this week and ask what the full cost of the role would be where you are. If it is hard, you have just saved yourself a hire you were not ready for.

If what is really behind this is that the business depends on you for everything, read I do everything myself and clients only want me first. If the extra work is coming from one big client, our guide to when one client is half your income is worth reading before you take on a wage to serve them.

try it free

Put this into practice with Billbooks

Create, send, and track invoices. Get paid faster, no spreadsheet gymnastics.

Start free

Keep reading

More from Small business.

stay in the loop

Getting-paid tips, once a month

Short, practical, no spam. The best of the blog plus new tools, straight to your inbox.

Suggest a feature for Billbooks

    Use Billbooks your way

    Submit an enquiry